Can you get unbreakable charms after banishing?

I agree it is intended behaviour! I used the word "fix" because I was projecting my own viewpoint on the matter - I do feel that it is unfair to punish players like that without warning. And yes, I also dislike the amount of Zote-related content that can be missed - I wonder if TC would have included the "neglect" option if the game had released with the Grey Prince Zote stuff and the Eternal Ordeal (I imagine Eternal Ordeal is still available if you neglect zote, but it is definitely not as interesting if you are missing the context on his character).

By the way, I say all this despite never having been unintentionally locked out of content.

Can you get unbreakable charms after banishing?

Cant get unbreakable charms after troupe left

I already have the unbreakable heart but still have fragile greed and strength. I banished the troupe but now divine is gone. Is there any other way to get the unbreakable charms? Also, I didnt get to fight NKG before I banished them.

Showing 1-2 of 2 comments

Can you get unbreakable charms after banishing?

Nope. That's the point of banishing them. You skip out on fighting NKG and getting the highest tier Grimmchild charm, in exchange for that other charm that has a chance to save you from damage.

At least Divine is kind enough to leave whatever charm you gave her without upgrading back in Dirtmouth. I had given her my Fragile Strength in my first playthrough and thought it was smart to see what Banishing did. Thought I was screwed out of the Strength since Leg Eater doesn't offer you a new one when you do that. But revisiting her old tent spot, I found my charm lying on the ground there.

Can you get unbreakable charms after banishing?

Showing 1-2 of 2 comments


Can you get unbreakable charms after banishing?

Soup

Can you get unbreakable charms after banishing?
8 May, 2018 @ 5:14pm

(SPOILERS) About banishing grimm...

So I was a dumbass and banished grimm before i reinforced the last fragile charm, is there any way to do that after banishing him, and if no, can i edit my save file to be the way it was before i made the decision?

Showing 1-7 of 7 comments

Can you get unbreakable charms after banishing?

Unfortunately not, once you've banished the Troupe there's no way to get Unbreakable Charms. Fortunately, upgrading them doesn't count for any completion.Not sure about the save editing.

Can you get unbreakable charms after banishing?

Soup

Can you get unbreakable charms after banishing?
8 May, 2018 @ 8:19pm 

Yea but it's the strength one that I forgot to upgrade and I wanted that for bosses and stuff :/ hence the save file editing

Last edited by Soup; 8 May, 2018 @ 8:19pm

Can you get unbreakable charms after banishing?

Dani

Can you get unbreakable charms after banishing?
8 May, 2018 @ 9:13pm 

Originally posted by Soup:

Yea but it's the strength one that I forgot to upgrade and I wanted that for bosses and stuff :/ hence the save file editing

thats the only one i bothered upgrading tbh x3

Can you get unbreakable charms after banishing?

the girl shop should still be there after banishing in Lifeblood update.

Can you get unbreakable charms after banishing?

Soup

Can you get unbreakable charms after banishing?
9 May, 2018 @ 4:00am 

the girl shop should still be there after banishing in Lifeblood update.

Nope, all of the tents, signs and everything still disappear like they would normally

Can you get unbreakable charms after banishing?

Keba

Can you get unbreakable charms after banishing?
9 May, 2018 @ 4:24am 

Divines tent only stays if you beat NKG without upgrading all fragile charms. After upgrading all 3, there is still the Legeater until her tent disappears.

As much as I know, banishing the Troupe removes all tents without the upgrades, leaving you with fragile charms.

Last edited by Keba; 9 May, 2018 @ 4:26am

Can you get unbreakable charms after banishing?

Soup

Can you get unbreakable charms after banishing?
9 May, 2018 @ 2:13pm 

:P is there a way to edit my save so the charm is unbreakable then? That's all I really care about tbh

Showing 1-7 of 7 comments


What happens if you banish the Grimm Troupe?

If the Grimm Troupe is banished, Brumm disappears, and an amnesic bug named Nymm appears in Dirtmouth who greatly resembles him. If the Knight chooses to leave the room before breaking the brazier, Brumm disappears and Banishment is unavailable forever.

How do you get unbreakable charms?

Unbreakable Strength Acquisition.
Location: Dirtmouth..
Acquisition: This charm is acquired by upgrading its fragile version from Divine - right after The Knight has summoned the Grimm Troupe, Divine will be available to interact with in Dirtmouth..

What charm do you get for banishing Grimm?

If you do choose to banish the Troupe, return to Dirtmouth to find an NPC named Nymm, who will give you the Carefree Melody Charm in place of the Grimmchild.

Do unbreakable charms count towards completion?

Making charms unbreakable counts to nothing. It just makes them unbreakable.