Is Abandoned movie a true story?

6/10

Weirdly uneven, yet mostly watchable.

Warning: Spoilers

It's hard to quantify this odd little film.

Based on a true story, it is somewhat interesting yet ultimately unsatisfying; moderately thrilling, yet strangely dull; occasionally uplifting yet mostly depressing.

The most consistent thing about it is how inconsistent it is.

For the majority of the scenes at sea I despised each of the men and hoped that they would die horribly, yet when they reached land and were welcomed with such contempt and hostility by the media and the public I found myself rooting for them and hoping for their vindication.

In essence I think I would have to describe this film as a maddeningly uneven depiction of a maddeningly unlikely true story about a maddeningly unlikable quartet of men. How close to the truth it really is will never be known, and that is perhaps the most maddening thing of all.

Frustrating in many respects, yet worth a watch if you're in the right mood.

14 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

9/10

Authentic sea story

I watched this with a few sailing friends and all, myself included, were impressed. It is a sea story well told.

But let's stand back from the actual real events for a moment. Here's a film that departs from the current trend in several important and positive directions: The story-line is clear. The voices are intelligible (even if the accent is from the far side of the globe for me). The flash-backs are clearly differentiated from the front-line story. There are not 1026 sub-plots. There is no sexual spicing up of the main story. As far as I could tell there was no subliminal advertising. What a pleasant change from the unintelligible mixup-gatherum of multi-plot nonsense that bombards us these days.

Now back to the sea. I found the story moved along nicely with variations in mood and happenings. It is rare for a true story to be so well told and to maintain interest. It even had the authenticity of a self-righteous skipper who was lavish in his criticism of his crew. My sailing friends wondered why he had no real crew in the first place. Yes, indeed.

Would this appeal to a non-sailing audience? I think it would. There is not exactly an excess of sailing jargon and the four main characters have an adequate range of personalities to maintain interest. Don't expect dramatic back-ground music and people posing on the bow! The story.is a true one and it shows.

The film is known by two different titles, "Abandoned" and "Stranded", neither of which really match the story but then almost any other title would give away too much.

One thought to finish with: one of the most important things to have when your boat is taking a tumble is a mirror.

17 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

9/10

The right side up

This film is based on a true story, which makes it very interesting. It's a survival tale set on top of a giant collection of water we call the ocean.

The production is convincing and maintains immersion. I thought the casting was perfect, and the actors do an excellent job conveying their characters.

I scored the film high because I felt it presented different aspects of the human spirit which is observed through the characters response and interaction to the situation, themselves and each other.

There is no waste or filler in the film, everything is well paced and contributes to the story which is well written.

I love stumbling on rare gems like this.

29 out of 36 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

8/10

Sailing movie about capsized trimaran & crew

Made for TV movie (true story) about a capsized trimaran yacht and how it's crew survived for over 100 days. Well done and reasonably accurate about the sailing offshore in a performance multi-hull. Unlike most disaster / redemption films this one obviously was done by people who knew their topic.

I enjoyed this film as unlike most it made me feel they did not dumb down the content assuming everyone watching could not truly understand the situation. As a sailor I found this film quite realistic.

I feel the actors did a good job of representing the people in the crisis and they avoided overacting with restraint.

I'd heard about this situation and the controversy, so seeing the film added a lot of context to news from the other side of the world.

29 out of 35 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

7/10

Ok

It was a good movie but they were lost at sea in an overturned boat for 4 months and the chubby guy never lost weight and his crew cut hair stayed the same short length the whole time lol. It was so distracting because I kept wondering how he's giving himself buzz cuts and why on earth it was even a priority to give himself crew cuts during this 4 month life threatening situation. Other than that, it was a good movie.

18 out of 30 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

10/10

Everyone said this is a hoax, a scam, fraud - until the NZ cops said "No! It Happened!"

Warning: Spoilers

120 days at sea with no food or water. How did these four Blokes from New Zealand survive? That's the entire premise for this movie and relates the true story of these brave hapless souls. Its mesmerizing viewing for the movie audience and I strongly recommend ABANDONED (10 stars) for all ages since there is no nudity or swearing. Why this movie didn't get a bigger audience is beyond me. Perhaps its because no "A" list celebrity starred in it or because it wasn't "shot" in Hollywood by a major studio, I don't know. Its movies like these, that a person discovers on there own, that makes movie watching worthwhile. The script in ABANDONED is good, it has excellent production quality, its well directed and the actors are very credible. SEE THIS MOVIE!

15 out of 22 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

6/10

Acting was...

Substandard. Almost detracted from the story. Seems like the story was told from one persons point of view.

5 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

7/10

Enjoyable True Story

Warning: Spoilers

This is based upon a true story

In 1989 four men set sail from Picton, NZ to Tonga in a Trimaran Yacht (google it) when a Rogue Wave capsizes the boat upside down and 119 days later they land on the Great Barrier Island.

We have heard of Rogue Agents in spy movies, but a Rogue Wave? Actually, there is such a thing and it can also actually endanger large ships. (You googled it, right?)

Of the 4-men on board only one, the owner of the boat, John (Peter Feeney) was a seasoned sailor and everything he owned was tied up into the boat called the Rose Noelle. The others Jim (Dominic Purcell), Rick (Owen Black), and Phil (Greg Johnson) were along for the adventure and had family who learned later there was no hope of a rescue as no search party could locate them. John had no family and the boat was all that he had.

Of course, there were bumps along the way and they had to learn to work together to survive. The most important item a licensed marine radio was not on board as John didn't want to endure the expense, and, of course, this set the others against him in a heart beat.

The photography was sensational as was the acting by all. Nothing was overdone. They learned how to capture fish and Phil remarked that they had so much food, they should have others over and this brought on a few chuckles.

At one point they spied a sailing ship in the distance and tried to send smoke signals, which didn't work. I wondered why they didn't use mirrors glinting off the sun that would be seen even at a great distance. Why indeed?

At the end, when they told their story government officials did not believe them nor did the New Zealand populace for the most part. How could they survive 119 days without anyone seeing them? It wasn't possible they said. The government launched an investigation.

Over all this was a very enjoyable true story. Watch to the end to see what happened to all of them. John, who lost everything probably wrote the story that became this movie.

If there is a lesson to be learned it is: make sure there is a good marine radio on board should you venture out onto the high seas. You just never know. (7/10)

Violence: Not really. Sex: No. Nudity: No. Language: Some in the beginning, then it went away.

10 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

9/10

This movie will Stick with you for a while!!

One of the best Sea survival movie I've ever watched! Keeping aside all of the controversy whether it actually happened or not, just watch this one as a great story which has too many emotions involved, top notch acting, great screenplay and cinematography!! This is one movie that makes your heart feel heavy, in the end!!

6 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Doesn't quite deliver

OK, but doesn't quite deliver on its promise, yet it's still very watchable nonetheless. A little bit sketchy on the meaty parts of the story and a bit too padded out on the bits that are less important. Kind of like 'Cast Away', but on a boat and less gripping.

3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

6/10

called stranded on amazon

Warning: Spoilers

I really felt sory for the albatrose, was quite dull but ending was better, was a true story

4 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

8/10

Otherwise known as Stranded

This is a great survival story and very realistically portrayed. Can't really fault it and in fact wish it had gone into more detail. I especially enjoyed the way each individual coped and it seemed like a very honest account. Highly recommended as an uplifting story of these blokes will to survive against all odds.

3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

8/10

Good because it's true.

I loved this because it was based on true events. Thus you can't ask for too much drama, or action if it never happened, always worth a watch.

If this was just a movie on it's own, it would have been boring, and slow, but luckily it wasn't.

3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

None of them looks like being lost in the sea for 119 days ...

It's not a bad movie, the only problem is that none of them looks like being lost in the sea for 119 days. I'll take that as a production error, for instance, movies like Cast Away, Life of Pi, ... actors would gradually "look" like they've been lost in the sea for that long (skinny, tanned, sun burned, dehydrated, messy long hairs, dirty, torn clothes, ... etc..). But in the movie "Abandoned", actors look about the same from the beginning to the end (check Dominic Purcell's hair ...). Also, most of these types of movies, it will either emphasize the scientific/technical parts, or the mental/spiritual aspects of human, but this movie just very lightly grazed through any of it, and it's a movie that leaves no impact, no thoughts after.

16 out of 30 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

4/10

Uninspired

It's amazing they were able to turn what, on paper, is a truly epic and harrowing tale into something so bland, one-dimensional, and utterly anticlimactic. Usually movies are able to dramatize and add a level of excitement beyond the real life events that inspired them. This movie somehow managed to do the opposite. I honestly didn't think that was possible.

10 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

7/10

A watchable movie

This is not the kind of movie I would see twice, however, it was interesting enough for me to watch it to the end. It was uneven at times, but because it is based on a true life adventure and probably a book, I guess that was inevitable. It had alot of character study of the four crewmen and made me involved enough to ask myself what would I do with each of these characters if I was a crewmember on that capsized trimaran. So it was a worthwhile movie to watch.

3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

8/10

Great tension that unbelievably really took place

this is truly are great movie. The story is told in a very "natural" fashion, concentrating on the inner feelings of the protagonists. still at no time there is something as length in this film. in opposite its the "little" motions, sudden turns and details that keep the tension up. Dominic Purcell is acting brilliantly and his fellow sailors are doing great as well. I would - just for cinematic reasons of course - hope for a second part. The actual incident was really dramatic, so I really do not want anything like this happen in the real world. I like movie setting in which more or less random people are bound together in a close room or so like "12 angry men". this picture could become one of the cult movies showing how different men cope with critical situations

7 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

8/10

4 Survivors in the Ocean...

Miraculous survival story. Upside down ship in the Ocean for 119 days. We liked it. It's a good drama movie to watch with the family.

2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

I expected it to be a bad movie . Because Dominic had let me down in the last two .

But this was entertaining in a made for television genre . I never have ten lines of info to say about a film . So the rest of this review will be something that has nothing to do with this movie .At the age of two, Dominic and his family moved from England to Sydney's Bondi and then moved to the Western Suburbs. After becoming a landscape gardener, he soon tired of the profession and, whilst watching the war movie Platoon (1986), decided to become an actor. Due to his working-class background, acting seemed a very unlikely choice of career, so he didn't pursue it until sometime later. He studied at The Australian Theatre for Young People (ATYP) and then later enrolled at the Western Australian Academy of Performing arts where he met his future wife Rebecca and studied with Hugh Jackman.

In 1997, Dominic scored a role in the TV series Raw FM (1997) and then landed a part in Mission: Impossible II (2000), which was filmed in Australia. He was soon spotted by a US talent scout and went off to LA. Since then, Dominic has been working constantly with roles in the movie Equilibrium (2002), the TV show John Doe (2002), Blade: Trinity (2004), and in the upcoming thriller Three Way (2004) and a new police television drama, Strut. - IMDb Mini Biography By: Aeryn

9 out of 62 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

10/10

1st review

Just a beautiful well acted heartwarming film. Cant beat a true story either.

3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

4/10

An adventure is...

Warning: Spoilers

This a man vs. Nature and man vs. Man story that is more interesting than entertaining. Maybe it's the acting which boarders on amateurish. Or the lack of a main character to root for. Or the portrayal of the crew as self-centered for the most part and prone to incredibly stupid behavior. All of that seemed to kill the tension. And this film needed more. Right from the opening scene where a crew...if you can call it that, with little or no sailing experience signs on for a blue water trek that will take weeks are taken on by a captain that seems to be winging it, the viewer gets the feeling that this is going to be a mess. And it doesn't take long for lack of experience, preparedness and assorted character flaws to combine for a 'gang that couldn't sail straight' disaster. And that's before they're in real peril!

Of all the flaws this film exhibits, the biggest is its lack of tension. If an adventure is a tragedy that doesn't happen...but could, then the feeling that tragedy isn't going to occur lets a lot of air out of the film.

0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

5/10

Ugh - can't anyone make a sailing movie?

One can hardly ever critique a true story. And while I was pretty cynical of this one as soon as it left the docks, by the end I'd softened a bit. If you endeavor to take this journey, just DON'T expect much more than one-dimensional writing and out-dated, cliche' characterizations of sailors, and non-sailors, when at sea.

The real-life event took place in the eighties. It seems as though the screenplay was written then too, only recently found washed up on some beach somewhere, serving as an oddly quaint reminder of simpler story telling days gone by. It's so bad in so many ways, but somehow still pleasantly nostalgic in the end. Start with a low bar, and you may enjoy it enough to survive with a decent level of satisfaction in the end, like you'd just eaten some bland but healthy meal.

3 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

8/10

my favorite genre, done so well

I could not stand up to do anything else except watch the movie from start to finish. It was excellent. The story, thrill, excitement, drama, even some action. Very refreshing story.

1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

8/10

A masterpiece

For the people: This movie is a masterpiece in terms of screenplay and reality depiction. The journey of four men stuck on water and their struggle is real. By the people.

1 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

8/10

A journey to the sea and self

Warning: Spoilers

It seemed to me totally Joseph Conradic. It talks about faith. Is a journey to the sea, and when the ship turns, as if the whole world turns. And they go through heart of darkness, hell. And in that hard situation every person becomes more himself, shows his more true personality that is hidden inside of him. So, it sails both through sea and through self. And captain is the guider through both worlds, who is familiar to both. He is like Dante,both have lost their loved ones(for captain it happens twice, the second time when he loses his ship, which is a sign of her). And also it is insisted more directly at the end, when wearing a wreath.

1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink