Why does the senate sometimes need to form a committee of the whole?

"All Legislative Powers herein granted shall be vested in a Congress of the United States, which shall consist of a Senate and House of Representatives."

Article I, Section 1, of the United States Constitution 

The chief function of Congress is the making of laws.  The legislative process comprises a number of steps, and this page provides information concerning legislation introduced and considered in Congress.  

A much more in-depth discussion and presentation of the overall legislative process are available in the Library of Congress’s How Our Laws are Made and Enactment of a Law.  

The legislative process in a nutshell:

  • First, a Representative sponsors a bill. 
  • The bill is then assigned to a committee for study. 
  • If released by the committee, the bill is put on a calendar to be voted on, debated or amended. 
  • If the bill passes by simple majority (218 of 435), the bill moves to the Senate. 
  • In the Senate, the bill is assigned to another committee and, if released, debated and voted on. 
  • If the Senate makes changes, the bill must return to the House for concurrence.  
  • The resulting bill returns to the House and Senate for final approval. 
  • The President then has 10 days to veto the final bill or sign it into law.

INTRODUCTION AND REFERRAL TO COMMITTEE

Any Member in the House of Representatives may introduce a bill at any time while the House is in session by simply placing it in the “hopper” at the side of the Clerk's desk in the House Chamber. The sponsor's signature must appear on the bill, which may have an unlimited number of cosponsoring Members. The bill is assigned its legislative number by the Clerk and referred to the committee of jurisdiction, which is the committee charged with review of the bill.

COMMITTEE HEARINGS AND REPORTS

The House of Representatives divides its work among over twenty permanent committees.  After a bill is introduced and referred to the committee of jurisdiction, the committee will often send the measure to its specialized subcommittee(s) for study, hearings, revisions, and approval.

Usually, the first step in this process is a public hearing where the committee or subcommittee members hear witnesses representing various viewpoints on the measure.  After hearings are completed, the bill is considered in a session that is popularly known as the “mark-up” session.  At this point, amendments may be offered to the bill, and the committee or subcommittee Members vote to accept or reject these changes.  At the conclusion of deliberation, a vote of committee or subcommittee Members is taken to determine what action to take on the measure. It can be reported, with or without amendment, or tabled, which means no further action on it will occur.  Tabling effectively “kills” the measure.  If the committee has approved extensive amendments, they may decide to report a new bill incorporating all the amendments. This is known as a “clean bill,” which will have a new number.

A measure is ready for consideration by the full House after it has been reported by a committee.

DEBATE AND VOTE ON THE HOUSE FLOOR

Consideration of a measure by the full House can be a simple or very complex operation.  Sometimes, consideration may be governed by a “rule.”  A rule is itself a simple resolution, which must be passed by the House and that sets out the particular rules of debate for a specific bill (i.e. how much time will be allowed for debate, whether amendments can be offered, and other matters).

Debate time for a measure is normally divided between proponents and opponents. Each side yields time to those Members who wish to speak on the bill.  When amendments are offered, these are also debated and voted upon.  After all debate is concluded and amendments decided upon, the House votes on final passage.

In some cases, a vote to “recommit” the bill to committee is requested. This is usually an effort by opponents to change some portion or table the measure. If the attempt to recommit fails, a vote on final passage is ordered.

Votes may be taken by the electronic voting system, which registers each individual Member's response. These are referred to as recorded votes, and are available in the record of roll call votes.  Votes in the House may also be by voice vote; in that instance, no record of individual responses is available. 

SENATE ACTION

After a measure passes in the House, it goes to the Senate for consideration.  This includes consideration by a Senate committee or subcommittee, similar to the path of a bill in the House.  A bill must pass both bodies in the same form before it can be presented to the President for signature into law.

RESOLVING DIFFERENCES

If the Senate changes the language of the measure, it must return to the House for concurrence or additional changes.  This back-and-forth negotiation may occur on the House floor, with the House accepting or rejecting Senate amendments or complete Senate text.

Often, a conference committee will be appointed with both House and Senate Members.  This group will resolve the differences in committee and report the identical measure back to both bodies for a vote. Conference committees also issue reports outlining the final version of the measure.

CONSIDERATION BY THE PRESIDENT

After a measure has been passed in identical form by both the House and Senate, it is considered “enrolled.”  The enrolled bill is sent to the President who may sign the measure into law, veto it and return it to Congress, let it become law without signature, or at the end of a session, pocket-veto it.

Why does the senate sometimes need to form a committee of the whole?

Why does the senate sometimes need to form a committee of the whole?

Why does the senate sometimes need to form a committee of the whole?

Why does the senate sometimes need to form a committee of the whole?

act – A measure passed by one or both Chambers. Usually refers to a measure passed by both Chambers in identical format and signed into law by the president or passed over a veto.

adjourn – To end a day’s session.

adjournment sine die – [Latin: without day] The final adjournment of a session of a Congress.

advice and consent – The role of the Senate to confirm presidential nominations for executive and judicial posts and international treaties.

About the Senate & the U.S. Constitution | Advice and Consent: Nominations and Treaties

amendment – A proposal to alter the text of a pending bill or other measure by striking out part of it, inserting new language, or both.

amendment in the nature of a substitute – An amendment that would strike out the entire text of a bill or other measure and insert a different text. Also called a "substitute amendment."

amendment tree – A way of diagramming the Senate amendment process. “Filling the amendment tree” refers to a process by which a certain number and type of amendments are offered under Senate precedents. Once these amendments are offered and the “tree is filled” no other amendments are allowed. See the Congressional Research Service (CRS) report, Filling the Amendment Tree in the Senate (PDF).

appropriation – A provision of funds for federal agencies to make payments out of the Treasury for specified purposes.

For additional information on appropriations go to Legislation & Records.

authorization – A statutory provision that obligates funding for a federal program or agency. An authorization establishes the terms and conditions under which the program or agency operates, authorizes the enactment of appropriations, and specifies how appropriated funds are to be used.

bill – A proposal to enact or repeal laws.

budget authority – Authority provided by law to enter into obligations that will result in outlays of federal funds.

For additional information on the budget process go to Legislation & Records.

budget resolution – A concurrent resolution setting forth the congressional budget by establishing various budget totals and dividing spending totals into functional categories (e.g., transportation). It sometimes includes reconciliation instructions to designated Senate or House committees.

For additional information on the budget process go to Legislation & Records.

Calendar of Business – A publication that contains information on bills and resolutions eligible for floor action, published each day the Senate is in session. Also referred to popularly as the Senate Calendar or the Legislative Calendar.

Calendar of Business

caucus – An informal organization of members of the Senate or House, or both, that exists to discuss issues of mutual concern and possibly to perform legislative research and policy planning for its members. There are regional, political, ideological, and ethnic caucuses.

class – A grouping of senators who are up for election in the same year. Article I, section 3 of the Constitution divides senators into three classes, Class I, Class II, and Class III. Each class is elected two years apart.

cloakroom – A room adjacent to the House or Senate Chamber that serves as a gathering place for members of the same party to discuss Chamber business privately. There is a cloakroom for each party.

closed session – A meeting of the House or Senate from which the public and press are excluded. Used for deliberations during impeachment trials or to discuss issues of national security, confidential information, or sensitive communications from the president. Also referred to as a secret session.

committee – A subgroup of the House or Senate established for the purpose of considering legislation, conducting hearings and investigations, or carrying out other assignments as instructed by its respective Chamber.

Current Senate Committees

committee amendment – An amendment recommended by a committee when reporting a bill or other measure.

committee print – A publication used by committees for various purposes. Examples include the rules of each standing committee, drafts of bills or committee reports, and memorial tributes.

companion bill or measure – Similar or identical legislation introduced in the Senate and House.

concurrent resolution – A legislative measure dealing with matters affecting both Chambers, such as a congratulatory message to another country, a concurrent budget resolution, or the creation of a temporary joint committee. Concurrent resolutions are not submitted to the president and thus do not have the force of law.

conferees – Members appointed to serve on conference committees. Charged with upholding their Chamber’s position on measures when negotiating with conferees from the other Chamber. Also called "managers."

conference committee – An ad hoc panel composed of Senate and House conferees formed for the purpose of reconciling different versions of a measure after passage in each Chamber. See "What is a Conference Committee?"

continuing resolution – A joint resolution enacted by Congress to provide budget authority for federal agencies and programs to continue operating in the absence of regular appropriations. Also referred to as continuing appropriations.

controlled time – A unanimous consent agreement that limits the time for debate on a bill or other measure and places it under the control of the floor managers. Each manager then allows any senator to participate in debate by yielding a specified amount of time to the senator.

enacted legislation – Legislation that has passed both Chambers of Congress in identical form and has become law by signature of the president, a pocket veto, or a veto override.

engrossed bill – The official copy of a bill or joint resolution passed and certified by one Chamber.

enrolled bill – The final copy of a bill or joint resolution that has passed both Chambers in identical form and has been signed by the appropriate Senate and House officials and submitted to the president for signature.

ex officio membership – The practice under Senate or House rules that allows the chairman and ranking member of a committee to participate as members of any subcommittees of that committee, with the exception that they are not generally permitted to vote.

executive business – The consideration of nominations and treaties, so called because they are received from the president rather than introduced by senators.

executive communication – A message sent to the Senate by the president or other executive branch official, such as a presidential veto message.

executive session – Any time during the Senate's daily session when it considers executive business.

filibuster – An attempt to block or delay Senate action on a bill or other matter by debating it at length, by offering numerous procedural motions, or by any other delaying or obstructive actions. See About Filibusters and Cloture for additional information.

fiscal year – The accounting period for the federal government that begins on October 1 and ends on September 30. The fiscal year is designated by the calendar year in which it ends; for example, fiscal year 2013 began on October 1, 2012, and ended on September 30, 2013. Congress passes appropriations legislation to fund the government for every fiscal year.

floor – The physical space where the Senate as a whole conducts its business; also used to refer informally to that space during a Senate session. Action "on the floor" is that which occurs as part of the Senate proceedings. A senator who has been recognized to speak by the chair is said to "have the floor" and when he or she is done speaking, “yields the floor.”

floor amendment – An amendment offered by an individual senator or representative from the floor during consideration of a bill or other measure, in contrast to a committee amendment.

floor leader – The chief spokesperson for each party in the Senate and House who is responsible for managing and scheduling business. Elected by the party conferences. Also called the majority leader and minority leader.

floor manager – Senators or representatives designated to lead consideration of a bill or other measure on the floor. Usually the chair and ranking minority member of the reporting committee or their designee.

germane – Pertaining to the subject of the pending bill or other business. Senate rules permit nongermane amendments in all but a few specific circumstances. See the CRS report, Germaneness of Debate in the Senate (PDF).

hold – An informal practice by which a senator informs Senate leadership that he or she does not wish a particular measure or nomination to reach the floor for consideration. See the CRS report, “Holds” in the Senate (PDF).

joint committee – A committee that includes membership from both Chambers of Congress, usually established with a narrow jurisdiction and lacking authority to report legislation. Chairmanship usually alternates between the Senate and House members from Congress to Congress.

joint explanatory statement – A document produced by a conference committee that addresses the differences between versions passed by the Senate and House and explains the conferees’ agreement. Also referred to as a “managers’ statement."

joint resolution – A legislative measure frequently employed for such matters as constitutional amendments, continuing appropriations, establishing permanent joint committees, and corrections of errors in existing law, and the vehicle most often used for congressional approval and disapproval, though it can be used for any legislative matter. Becomes law when approved by both Chambers and signed by the president, except for a proposed constitutional amendment, which requires a two-thirds affirmative vote in each Chamber and ratification by three-quarters of the states.

joint session – A session in which the Senate and House meet together to conduct formal business or to hear an address by the president of the United States.

Journal of the Senate – The written record of the official proceedings of the Senate, required by Article I, section 5 of the U.S. Constitution. Includes motions and votes but not debates. Separate journals are kept for each Chamber, as well as for legislative, executive, closed, and impeachment proceedings.

Journal of the Senate of the United States (GPO – govInfo)

"lame duck" session – The time following the November general elections in an even-numbered year. So called because some of the lawmakers who take part will not be returning for the next Congress.

Lame Duck Sessions (1940 to Present)

layover – Informal term for the requirement in various Senate rules that a measure or matter lie over one or two days before Senate action is in order. For example, when a bill or other measure is reported from committee, it may be considered on the floor only after it “lies over” for one legislative day, and if the measure is reported with a written report, after the written report has been available for two calendar days. Nominations and treaties must lie over one day. Layover periods may be waived by unanimous consent. Some fast-track statutes waive the layover requirement so that it is in order to proceed immediately to a measure.

legislative day – The time between when the Senate convenes and adjourns. Usually one day, though may extend over several days or even weeks or months.

legislative session – Any time during the Senate's daily session in which it considers legislative business (bills, resolutions, and related actions).

lie on the table – See motion to table.

line-item veto – A veto of part rather than all of an appropriations act. As the law currently stands, the president must sign or veto the entire act and may not issue a line-item veto. For additional information see the CRS Report, Regular Vetoes and Pocket Vetoes: In Brief (PDF)

majority leader – The floor leader for the majority party.

markup – The process by which congressional committees and subcommittees debate, amend, and rewrite proposed legislation.

measure – Proposed legislation on which the Senate or House takes action, such as a bill or resolution.

minority leader – The floor leader for the minority party.

morning business – Routine business that occurs during the first two hours of a legislative day or at other times by unanimous consent. Includes receiving messages from the president and the House, executive branch reports, committee reports, and the introduction of bills and submission of resolutions.

motion to instruct conferees – A proposal to instruct conferees appointed to a conference committee to take a certain position in the conference. Such instructions are not binding. See the CRS report, Instructing Senate Conferees (PDF).

motion to proceed to consider – A proposal, usually offered by the majority leader, to bring a measure, nomination, or treaty up for floor consideration, including debate and votes. Usually used when unanimous consent to do so cannot be obtained.

motion to reconsider – A proposal to revisit any question previously decided by vote. May only be offered once after each vote and may only be offered by a member of the winning side. Usually followed by a “motion to table” that secures the outcome of the vote.

motion to table – A proposal to set aside any pending question. Used to dispose of a question the Chamber does not want to consider further. Agreement to the motion is equivalent to defeating the question tabled.

nomination – An appointment by the president to executive or judicial office. Subject to Senate confirmation.

Nominations

original bill – A bill drafted by a committee instead of one drafted by a member and referred to committee.

oversight – Review of the activities of a federal agency or program by a committee.

parliamentarian – The Senate or House adviser on the interpretation of its rules and procedures. Duties also include referring bills to the appropriate committees.

parliamentary inquiry – A question from the floor to the presiding officer by a senator or representative requesting a clarification of the procedural situation on the floor.

party conference – An organization of all party members in a Chamber. Elects the party and committee leaders and assigns members to committees. Meets periodically to discuss political strategy and to review party positions on pending legislative business.

point of order – A claim made by a senator or representative from the floor that a rule of the Chamber is being violated.

policy committees – Democratic and Republican groups that provide research and other services to members of each party and also serve as a forum for discussion of party legislative strategy.

president of the Senate – The vice president. As presiding officer of the Senate, the vice president oversees sessions of the Senate and may vote in the case of a tie. In the absence of the vice president, the president pro tempore or a designee performs these duties, with the exception of voting.

president pro tempore – A constitutionally recognized officer of the Senate who presides over the Chamber in the absence of the vice president. Elected by the Senate and, by custom, the senator of the majority party with the longest record of continuous service.

presiding officer – A senator of the majority party who presides over the Senate in the absence of the president pro tempore. Charged with maintaining order and decorum, recognizing members to speak, and interpreting the Senate's rules, practices, and precedents.

private law – A bill applicable only to specific organizations or individuals that has passed both Chambers and is signed by the president.

pro forma session – A brief meeting of the Senate or House, often only a few minutes in duration, during which business is not usually conducted. For more information read the CRS report, Sessions, Adjournments, and Recesses of Congress (PDF).

proxy voting – The practice of allowing a senator to cast a vote in committee on behalf of an absent senator.

public law – A bill or joint resolution with general applicability nationwide that has passed both Chambers and is signed by the president.

question – Any matter on which the Senate is to vote, such as passage of a bill, adoption of an amendment, agreement to a motion, or an appeal.

quorum – The number of senators that must be present for the Senate or House to do business. The Constitution requires a majority of senators (51) and representatives (218) for a quorum.

ranking member – The highest-ranking (and usually longest-serving) minority member of a committee or subcommittee.

recess – A temporary interruption of Senate or House proceedings. A recess may extend for a few hours or overnight, or may constitute a long break, such as over a holiday period.

reconciliation – An optional process established by the Congressional Budget Act of 1974 (PDF) by which Congress changes existing laws to conform tax and spending levels to levels set in a budget resolution. Reconciliation instructions found in budget resolutions direct committees to report or submit to the Budget Committee legislation that would enact such changes, indicating appropriate dollar changes to be achieved and usually providing a deadline for committee action. The resulting legislation is a reconciliation bill.

referral – The process by which a bill is assigned to a committee for consideration. In the Senate, referrals are generally made to the committee with jurisdiction over the predominant subject matter in the bill or resolution, but measures may be referred to more than one committee by unanimous consent.

rider – A nongermane amendment to a bill or an amendment to an appropriation bill that changes the permanent law governing a program funded by the bill.

secretary, party – The party official responsible for working with the party floor leader to schedule legislation on the floor and inform senators of all pending business. Elected by the party conference. Also called the secretary for the majority and the secretary for the minority.

secretary of the Senate – The chief legislative, financial, and administrative officer of the Senate. Nominated by the majority party conference and elected by the Senate. Learn more about the secretary of the Senate.

select or special committee – A committee established by resolution to conduct a particular study or investigation. Usually established for a limited time period and often does not have the authority to report legislation.

Senate Manual – A document that contains the Senate's standing rules and orders and other laws and regulations that apply to the Senate, usually published once each new Congress.

Senate Manual (GPO – govInfo)

senator – A person elected or appointed to the Senate and duly sworn. The Constitution requires that a senator be at least 30 years old, a citizen of the United States for at least nine years, and an inhabitant of the state from which he or she is elected. There are two senators from every state and each is elected to a six-year term.

seniority – The status given senators according to their length of service. Entitles a senator with greater seniority to preferential treatment in matters such as committee assignments. Seniority lists are established by the party conferences.

sergeant at arms – The protocol officer and chief law enforcement officer of the Senate. Nominated by the majority party conference and elected by the Senate. Learn more about the sergeant at arms.

session – The period during which Congress assembles and conducts business. Each Congress generally has a first and second session roughly lasting a calendar year; historically, there have also been third and special sessions.

simple resolution – A measure used to express nonbinding positions of the Senate or House or to deal with either Chamber’s internal affairs, such as the creation of a special committee. Does not require action by the other Chamber and does not have the force of law.

slip law – The first official publication of a law, usually published a few days after a law has been enacted.

standing committee – A permanent committee established under the rules of the Senate or House, specializing in the consideration of particular subject areas.

star print – Corrected editions of congressional publications identifiable by stars printed in the lower left-hand corner of their title pages or covers. Takes precedence over the original print of a report or document.

Statutes at Large – A publication of the laws and concurrent resolutions enacted during each Congress, arranged in chronological order. Also includes presidential proclamations.

United States Statutes at Large (GPO – govInfo)

subcommittee – A sub-unit of a committee established for the purpose of dividing the committee's workload.

supplemental appropriation – Money provided in an appropriations act outside the regular appropriations cycle. Used to cover emergencies, such as disaster relief, or other needs deemed too urgent to be postponed until the enactment of the next year's regular appropriations acts.

unanimous consent – Agreement on any question or matter before the Senate that sets aside a rule of procedure to expedite proceedings. Many requests for unanimous consent (u.c.) are routine but if any senator objects, the request is rejected. A more complex unanimous consent agreement sets terms for the consideration of a specified bill or other measure, reflecting negotiations among senators interested in the measure. Examples include limiting time available for debate and only permitting a list of specified amendments to a measure.

United States Code – A compilation of general and permanent U.S. laws currently in force, organized by subject matter.

United States Code

veto override – The passage into law of a bill vetoed by the president. Requires a two-thirds vote in both Chambers.

vice president – See president of the Senate

voice vote – A vote in which the presiding officer states the question, asks those in favor and against to vote "yea" or "nay" respectively, and announces the result according to his or her judgment. The names and numbers of senators voting on each side are not recorded.

whip – An assistant to the majority or minority leader who is also elected by his or her party conference. Responsible for mobilizing votes within the party on major issues and often serves as acting floor leader.

yeas and nays – See roll call vote

yield – A member “yields the floor” when he or she is done speaking. “Yielding time” refers to a floor manager allowing a member a specified amount of time to speak under a time-limited debate. “Yielding for a question” means the senator who has the floor will entertain a question from another member who does not have the floor. Senators have the right to yield for questions while maintaining the floor—consent is not required for this to occur. If, however, a senator who holds the floor wants to engage in a colloquy or permit another senator to make a request of the Senate, propound an inquiry, or the like, that senator must ask consent to permit the other senator to act without surrendering the floor (e.g., “I ask to yield to the senator for such purpose without losing my right to the floor.”).