Shimenawa Hu Tao vs Crimson Witch

Q: Who is Shimenawa reminiscence good for?

Shimenawas Reminiscence Rating This set provides a good boost on ATK which can be useful for DPS Characters. The 2-piece set gives a powerful boost on ATK and would be a great alternative to Gladiators Finale, which has the same 2-piece set effect.

Posted by1 year ago

Table of Contents Show

About Community
Recommended for You
Is Crimson witch good for Hu Tao?
Does Hu Tao Proc Crimson witch?
Who is 4 pc Shimenawa good for?
Who is Shimenawa reminiscence good for?

Archived

Every time I look this up there is always a wall of text or a long video with comments saying otherwise. Can someone give me a TLDR?

This thread is archived

New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast

level 1

Crimson Witch is the safer option and does more damage with vape/melt reactions.

Shimenawa does more damage with your charged attacks, but you lose out on your Q usage (which limits your AOE and self-heal).

Damage wise overall, they're pretty comparable, but CW personally wins out since it doesn't ruin her burst. Shim can be better if you can kill in one rotation.

The only issue is that farming CW is a bitch, whereas farming Shim is pretty efficient since you can get EOSF pieces for other characters.

level 2

I disagree, SR can do more damage than CW even in reaction comps bcs (i could be wrong) i'm pretty sure that the reaction multiplier is applied after the artifact set bonus is applied.

level 2

I had asked the question before in the Keqing Main TC discord. Shimenawa's can generally give you more dmg, but the thing is it's linked to how good you are with Hu Tao. The better you are at animation cancelling, the better Shimenawa's can be because of the disgusting amount of extra CAs you can get and it can exceed CW, but CW is better if you don't want to do animation cancels.

The person I talked to was a TC'er who's doing a new Hu Tao guide for the KQM discord, jstern, if you want to hit the person up.

level 1

shimenawa will give you higher charge atks, but lower burst dmg- requires you to have energy at all times to get the boost (not a big deal)

crimson witch is just generally good for both, no perks needed for bonuses

level 1

SR is fine. You'll have great NA damage but you won't be able to E > Q in a pinch.

CW is well-rounded. Basically 22.5% Pyro Bonus and 80 EM.

2CW mix-set will get the job done. 15% Pyro Bonus + whatever mix set you chose to throw in.

SR will be more resin efficient because many supports benefit from Emblem set. CW is in a pool with LW which is a really niche set. Arguably longer to farm to due to the waves. Don't be afraid to experiment with mix sets. So long as you have great substats, you can never go wrong.

level 1

shimenawa gives big basic damage buff but removes to usefulness of her ult.

crimson witch has lower basic damage but allows you to nuke with her ult

level 1

For Vape - Crimson Witch.

If you only doing charge attacks - Shimenawa.

Emblem for a Quickswap.

Or just use any 2p/2p, if you have a better substats with that.

level 1

im using gladiator

perhaps it isnt the best

but it works

level 2

This! Ive seen a couple guides for childe and they all say that blackcliff warbow is ok but don’t “waste” your star glitter unless you have it already. I was going to use Amos’ bow on him (had extremely good artifacts, crit rate and dmg on all pieces except the goblet) until all of my artifacts rolled into def, hp and em which left me with 89% crit dmg (55 crit rate) which meant I kinda needed the warbow if I wanted a good ratio. It might not be his best in slot but it works, and that’s all that matters! Just go with what you need/have

level 1

4pc Shimenawa’s Reminiscence provides higher AA damage than 4CW but lowers your Elemental Burst damage which hurts your AoE damage, also if you're unable to burst, it might cause survivability issues if you're not running a healer

level 1

Honestly I have both for her and I prefer Shimenawa. Her burst hit reg is trash so it doesn't matter

About Community

This is the official community for Genshin Impact (原神), the latest open-world action RPG from HoYoverse. The game features a massive, gorgeous map, an elaborate elemental combat system, engaging storyline & characters, co-op game mode, soothing soundtrack, and much more for you to explore!

Create

Upload Video

My VideosData AnalysisManage Interactions

Home
Anime
Trending
Category

120 Views06/05/2022

bili_2134529809

0 Follower · 932 Videos